34 pages • 1 hour read
Apex Hides the Hurt is a meditation on the nature of naming. In mythology and folklore, giving something a name is associated with power: In the Bible, God gives the first man Adam the ability to name other creatures to cement his power over them; in fairy tales, learning the name of an entity like Rumpelstiltskin counters its magic. In politics and science, naming bestows ownership: For a long time, diseases were named after the doctors who first identified them; European travelers renamed the lands they encountered, considering them unclaimed territory.
In the novel, the protagonist’s profession divorces names from the objects they describe—the power of naming is separated from ownership. In the novel’s version of consumer culture, a product’s name is a key factor in its success, regardless of quality. Whitehead often mines comedy from this dissociation: By turning Luno into New Luno, the soft drink appealed to a younger demographic; giving a luxury automobile the meaningless name of “Q 100” added an air of prestige and mystique. Most menacingly, the protagonist fondly remembers coming up with the name “Redempta” (35), which led to his promotion—but the reader never learns what product was sold under this suggestive branding.
“Apex” is the prime example of the power of naming. As the protagonist notes, any product could be named Apex—the word sounds trustworthy and powerful but evokes nothing specific besides money: “The eye on the top of the pyramid as it appears on the dollar bill. He had heard this was a symbol of immense power according to mystics. What the mystics saw was Apex. It was the currency of the world” (99). Like “Q,” “Apex” is an abstraction, an empty container.
For the town of Winthrop, choosing the right name seems paramount. The town council and many of the residents believe that the town’s name will determine its future. The battle over the name pits uplifting history, in the form of Regina’s preference to return to the original name Freedom, against a legacy of white power; in the form of Albie’s desire to retain the name Winthrop, against the demands of capitalism to erase the past with an eye to a profitable future; in the form of Lucky’s commissioned name New Prospera.
The only counter to this fixation on names is the bartender Muttonchops, who argues that a place has a character embedded in it and changing its name will not matter. But the protagonist wonders whether the opposite is true, imagining a label that reads: “Warning: The Name Remains the Same, But Contents May Have Changed Over Time” (159). Either way, it is unclear whether a name can represent someone’s true self. Even the name Freedom, which seems to be the positive counter to the power of enslavers to give their own last names to those they’ve enslaved—the founders of the town chose its name for themselves—turns out to reflect a somewhat jaundiced view of human nature, as its creator eventually betrayed a fellow founder to rename the town Winthrop. The protagonist’s vision of a naming utopia, in which “citizens walked the streets, alone, in comfortable pairs, in ragged groups, with their true names blazing over their hearts, without pride or shame” (180-181), has yet to come true.
Most of the naming that happens in the novel is branding, that is conceiving a name for a product or service that makes it appealing to potential customers. However, branding also includes a distinctive set of design features—color, graphics, imagery, and catchphrases—that create a narrative for the product or service being sold. The clearest example of branding is Apex bandages. The protagonist is aware that he played only one part in the life cycle of product development: “He never did meet the guy who came up with the tagline [Apex hides the hurt], just like he never met the guy who came up with the idea [to make bandages in a variety of skin tones]” (110).
The novel explores the idea that branding is integral to the way people interact with one another. One way branding does this is by linking something particular with something shared or universal. The phrase “Hides the Hurt” becomes a meme joke because it can (sarcastically or literally) apply in many different scenarios. The broad meaning and the shared reference turn the product into a metaphor that everyone can understand. Branding also intrudes into human interaction when people start to believe (as consumer culture tells them) that the brands they choose represent their personalities. This is why Lucky hires the protagonist’s old company to come up with a new name: He wants the town’s new residents to identify with New Prospera, a brand that matches his capitalist vision.
Though the protagonist sees the world through the lens of branding, he acknowledges that it is a deception. He contrasts the “brands” that people put forward for society with their “true names,” which show a side of themselves they would rather keep hidden. He observes this dichotomy at the award ceremony and imagines words like “Liar,” “Bed Wetter,” and “Criminal” on the attendees’ nametags. The tag he gives himself is “Fugitive” (169). This search for truth-telling names culminates with the protagonist’s choice to call the town by its “true name”—Struggle. Ironically, however, this decision is not healing for the protagonist himself. Rather than fixing his limp, the choice of name causes his injury to hurt more as he retreats even further into self-isolation.
Whitehead presents a shifting and complex narrative of racism. In Winthrop, although historical imbalances have led to the kind of systemic racism that allows there to be a richer white section of town and a poorer Black section, an individual’s skin color does not necessarily determine their social position.
The town’s foundation seems to be a straightforward story of progress: Formerly enslaved people fled white supremacy in the South and formed an egalitarian community they named Freedom. But this version of the story glides over the fact that one of the town’s founders betrayed the other: Seduced by the promise of wealth, Abraham Goode sided with white business owner Winthrop, renaming the town and allowing Winthrop to establish his factory. Winthrop’s presence made the town more prosperous, but the fact that his family owned and inherited all the major establishments meant that they were enriched far more than the working families.
The Goode family prospered enough for their names to end up on street signs, but current descendant Regina had to move out of town to pursue opportunities she could not have found there. Now, Regina occupies a position of privilege: As mayor, she is a town celebrity and one of the town’s primary decision makers; however, there is the suggestion that her desire to give the town the old name Freedom means she is happy to gloss over the history of her ancestor’s misdeeds.
The protagonist also has a complex relationship with race. A Black man, he does not feel kinship with the other Black characters. When Regina appeals to his sense of Black history to get him to side with her name idea, the protagonist responds to the name Freedom with disdain at their attempts at optimism. The protagonist uses his status as a Quincy alumnus to bond with powerful white men, but is often on the receiving end of microaggressions like the reporter stereotyping him with the phrase “keeping it real” and Albie telling him about another Black Quincy student.
The novel argues that this lack of overt racism in the present day is not a sign of social progress. Rather, it is simply the whitewashing of trauma, which has the same long-term effects as the Apex bandages that “hide the hurt” while actually obscuring ongoing infection and necrotic tissue damage. It is not enough to simply rename the town Struggle—this name harks back to the founders’ trials in their escape from slavery and establishment of a free society, but it does little to address modern-day problems like gentrification and capitalism destroying civic institutions like the library. The renaming is similar to how Apex bandages come in a variety of skin tones—a product update that cares more about optics than actual healing. This is why the protagonist ends the novel with his foot pain worsening.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Colson Whitehead
African American Literature
View Collection
American Literature
View Collection
Black History Month Reads
View Collection
Books on U.S. History
View Collection
Business & Economics
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Laugh-out-Loud Books
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Satire
View Collection