59 pages • 1 hour read
Colson Whitehead is a prize-winning African American author. He was awarded a Pulitzer Prize as well as the National Book Award for The Underground Railroad (2016) and received a second Pulitzer for The Nickel Boys (2020). Although now known primarily as a novelist, after graduating from Harvard, Whitehead wrote for New York City paper The Village Voice. It was during his time covering local events that he began working on the book-length pieces that would become his first novels. Born and raised in New York City, Whitehead sets much of his work in and around Manhattan, and Crook Manifesto in particular represents his interest in the way that the city’s history has impacted its African American residents.
Whitehead’s work depicts the experiences of African Americans during the 19th, 20th, and 21st centuries, and his novels engage with such themes as slavery, reconstruction, racism, discrimination, institutional and systemic oppression, and representations of African Americans in popular culture. Though he is one of America’s most lauded contemporary producers of literary fiction, Whitehead’s diverse, versatile body of work draws from the conventions of genre fiction. The Intuitionist (1999) and Zone One (2011) are examples of Whitehead’s speculative fiction works, and Harlem Shuffle (2021) and Crook Manifesto (2023) represent his first forays into crime writing. John Henry Days (2001) and The Underground Railroad (2016) both bridge the gap between literary and historical fiction.
Both Harlem Shuffle and Crook Manifesto engage with many themes that appear in Whitehead’s earlier works. Racism, structural inequality, the politics of representation, and the relationship between corruption and power feature prominently in both Whitehead’s Ray Carney series and his previous novels. The Ray Carney novels also evidence a deep interest in New York City. Through these books, Whitehead seeks to paint a picture of a city (and a neighborhood—Harlem) in flux, to follow the stories of African Americans in New York through multiple eras, and to engage with the structural barriers that impacted Black communities in the second half of the 20th century.
Harlem Shuffle is the first book in the Ray Carney series, and it is here that Whitehead first introduces Carney—his entry into the canon of crime-solving protagonists. The year is 1959, and Ray lives with his wife, Elizabeth, who is pregnant with their second child. The owner of a furniture store in Harlem, Ray worries about money and wants to provide the best possible life for his family. Ray is an upstanding citizen, but he has a troubled past. His father, Mike, had been a small-time criminal, and his cousin Freddie, with whom he has a close friendship, is still involved in various criminal enterprises. Freddie asks Ray to help fence a necklace he plans to steal during a heist from the nearby Hotel Theresa. Although Freddie offers to share a portion of the profits, Ray plans to decline. However, when the heist goes awry and Freddie shows up at Ray’s store, desperate, necklace and coconspirators in tow, Ray agrees to help. This sets off a chain of events that ultimately leads to Freddie’s death and Ray’s permanent entrance into the world of fencing stolen goods. Whitehead also introduces several other characters who will feature prominently in Crook Manifesto, such as Pepper—a small-time criminal and confidant to Ray—and Zippo—an aspiring filmmaker whose work brings together people from wildly disparate social milieus. Ultimately, Ray prospers financially through the continued success of both his furniture store and his fencing operation. At the end of the novel, Ray contemplates his own trajectory, the changing landscape of Harlem, and the thin line between criminality and a law-abiding life. The stage is set for the next book. Although Crook Manifesto can be read as a standalone text, there are many links between it and Harlem Shuffle.
Although a vast, complex network of Black Power organizations existed during the 1970s, many of which had their roots in the Civil Rights era of the 1960s, Crook Manifesto is primarily interested in the division between the Black Panther Party and the Black Liberation Army. Founded by Huey P. Newton and Bobby Seale, the Black Panther Party was a Marxist-Leninist Black Power movement that sought to improve conditions for Black Americans. Initially willing to engage in violent acts, the Panthers ultimately expanded into social programming, providing free food for children, education programs, and community health and outreach operations. The Black Liberation Army was a much more militant organization. Their stated goal was to “take up arms” for the liberation of Black Americans, and they were markedly more willing than the Black Panthers to resort to violence to achieve their aims.
This tension is on full display in Crook Manifesto, where Ray and his family follow the feud between the two organizations closely, not only in the media but also on the streets of Harlem. As Ray notes, the Black Panther Party was a reform-based organization, meaning that they wanted to work within existing power structures to improve conditions for African Americans. In contrast, the BLA was a revolutionary movement. They openly stated that their goal was to overthrow the US government. The BLA was involved in countless attacks during the 1970s and was blamed for the deaths of multiple police officers. Support for the two organizations split communities, and this tension can be observed in Crook Manifesto.
A prominent (although fictional) BLA member, Malik Jamal is behind the jewel heist that propels much of the action in Part 1, and his character makes several more appearances in the text. This is one way that Whitehead engages with key sociocultural phenomena in 1970s-era Harlem, creating a detailed picture of what life was actually like for African Americans during that time. Many of the societal issues faced by Black Americans during the 1960s and 1970s were at the core of what the Black Power movement sought to change in America, and they too are on full display in Crook Manifesto: Harlem’s urban decay, high crime rates, inequality, and poor access to education and social services were all conditions that the Panthers and the BLA sought to change, and a discussion of those topics is woven through both the novel’s plot and its thematic concerns.
Blaxploitation was a subgenre of African American cinema that reached the peak of its popularity in the 1970s. Although initially independently produced, often low-budget, and aimed at Black audiences, Blaxploitation films became so popular that their viewership expanded to white audiences and Hollywood took an interest in producing its own Blaxploitation movies. The versatile canon of Blaxploitation cinema includes crime films, westerns, horror, martial arts movies, and even comedies. Steeped in pop-culture references and ’70s-era style and featuring loud, of-the-moment funk and soul soundtracks, these films often tackled important social issues. Race relations, discrimination, sexism, racism, and colorism were frequently at issue in Blaxploitation cinema.
Zippo’s original inspiration was Blacula, a real film produced in 1972, and Zippo’s own film evidences many key elements of Blaxploitation. His protagonist, Nefertiti, is a strong, female action hero. Zippo is clear that he means the film to be a compliment to Black women. His fictional film recalls real-life titles such as Foxy Brown. Blaxploitation was also heavily influenced by the Black Power movement of the 1970s, and many of these films can be viewed through that lens. Black characters were empowered, took center stage, and showcased sociopolitical issues of interest to Black audiences. They were not without controversy, and even the NAACP criticized the genre, but it remains an important piece of American cinematic history.
Crime fiction has long been a part of the American literary canon. Although it is often categorized as “genre fiction” and thus excluded from the culturally prestigious literary canon, there are many examples of crime novels that bridge the gap between art and entertainment. Crook Manifesto joins a host of other crime novels that examine New York’s dark, seedy underbelly. There is also an important tradition of Black-authored crime fiction, and Whitehead is very consciously choosing to sidestep his typical literary fiction to work within this subgenre. Chester Himes and Walter Mosley are two well-known figures within the world of Black-authored crime novels, but there are many others.
One key characteristic of Black-authored crime fiction is its willingness to engage with important societal issues such as racism, colorism, discrimination, and the overrepresentation of Black Americans in prisons and the foster-care system. Crook Manifesto, in its overt interest in the relationship between Corruption, Power, and Institutional Racism, can be placed squarely within this tradition. Like other Black authors who weave serious thematic content into novels meant for a popular audience, Whitehead uses a fast-paced, high-action plot to bring serious issues to the forefront. Rooted in a long tradition of plot-driven genre fiction, Crook Manifesto is also a serious work of literature.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Colson Whitehead