44 pages • 1 hour read
The repeating phrase “Shit Don’t Mean Shit” is an important motif throughout the novel, illustrating the theme of How Literature Shapes Lives. The phrase first appears as Jimmy Gold’s catchphrase, and both Morris and Pete repeat the phrase throughout the novel to help them get through difficult situations. For example, Morris uses it as a sort of mantra to help survive his time in prison. The phrase proves particularly important during the novel’s climax, as Pete contemplates lighting the notebooks on fire. He realizes The Dangers of Obsession as he compares himself to Morris: They have both become obsessed with the Gold trilogy and allowed it to control their lives. However, Pete proves his ultimate freedom from Gold when he modifies the catchphrase to reflect his realization that his sister matters more than the notebooks: There is, in fact, “some kind of shit that means shit” (398). He, like Gold, realizes that life is not completely pointless, as the phrase “shit don’t mean shit” implies. Rather, his family actually does mean something to him. At the end of the novel, Jerome also gifts Holly with a shirt with the phrase printed on it, suggesting that the phrase was meaningful to them, as well.
When Morris’s parole officer, McFarland, speaks with him, Morris is slipping deeper into his obsession with the notebook. McFarland takes the opportunity to remind Morris that he can either be a “sheep,” following the rules of his parole and staying free, or he can be a “wolf” and cause trouble, adding that Morris is “too old to howl and much too old to run” (247). Soon after this conversation, Morris identifies himself as a “wolf,” and the wolf becomes a motif in the text. Morris consciously decides to embrace what he sees as the single-minded qualities of a wolf, using whatever dangerous and violent methods are necessary to get the notebooks back. This illustrates the theme of The Dangers of Obsession, as Morris ignores McFarland’s warnings and embraces his obsession over Rothstein’s notebooks.
Pete also compares Morris to a wolf. For instance, when Morris calls him after their first encounter at the bookstore, he asks Pete, “And who am I, exactly?” Pete thinks, “The wolf […]. You’re the big bad wolf” (358). Further, as Morris comes down to the basement where Pete is helping Tina, Pete thinks how they are “two little piggies in the basement and the big bad wolf upstairs […] and us without a house made of straw, let alone one made of bricks” (397). This allusion to the story “The Three Little Pigs” characterizes Morris as an angry, violent “wolf” who is bent on destroying anything in his path—including the lives of Pete and Tina—to get the notebooks back. It is important to mention that, while these depictions of wolves are in line with popular superstitions, they do not align with current research on the species.
“Finders Keepers” is both the title of the novel and the name of Hodges and Holly’s private detective agency. The phrase also refers to Morris and Pete’s struggle over ownership of the notebooks. Because Pete found the notebook and money, he uses them without much thought to who they belong to or where they came from; he found them, so they now belong to him. However, when Morris enters the picture, he demands that Pete return the books to him, believing that he is the rightful owner. When he first confronts Pete, he demands Pete return the notebooks, saying that Pete “stole” them. Ironically, Morris claims ownership of the notebooks and accuses Pete of theft though he stole them from Rothstein, claiming Rothstein deprived readers of them. Each of these characters claims ownership of the notebooks, and each of the others disputes that ownership. This emphasizes the themes of How Literature Shapes Lives and The Relationship Between Author and Readers. The complexity of the ownership of the notebooks lends meaning to the novel’s title, as Pete and Morris both become obsessed with Rothstein’s writing and believe they are personally the rightful owners of the material.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Stephen King