44 pages • 1 hour read
Flem finally returns to town, bringing with him a herd of ponies and a Texan horse hand. The ponies are vicious and untamed, but the Texan insists that they will settle down in a few days. The men, including Ratliff, argue over who owns the horses and who Snopes will convince to buy them. Ratliff declares he wouldn’t buy any animal from Flem. The ponies escape the barn, nearly killing Eck Snopes’s little boy Wall. The Texan continues to insist that the ponies are gentle. The Texan starts an auction for the horses, but the townspeople do not want to buy them. He finally offers a pony to Eck Snopes for free, provided that he’ll start the bidding on the next horse. This leads the townspeople to start bidding on the horses, not wanting to let Eck Snopes get two horses so cheaply.
One man, Henry Armstid, spends his last $5 on a pony, against his wife’s wishes. Flem arrives at the end of the auction. Henry asks the Texan to catch his horse for him, but the Texan says it’s Henry’s horse and that he can catch it himself. Henry tries, forcing his wife to help him, but it is evident he can’t do it. The Texan leads him and his wife out, giving her a dollar and telling her to take Henry home. Henry shouts that he wants his horse, but the Texan tells him to get his money from Flem the next day and sends him home. Flem collects the cash from the auction. The Texan leaves town, heading to Jefferson, while the men attempt to collect the ponies they have purchased. The horses once again break away, nearly killing Henry (who did not leave) and Wall. The pony the Texan gave Eck runs away, getting down the road to a bridge and attacking another farmer, Tull, in his wagon, rendering him unconscious.
Ratliff returns, and Will Varner arrives, and the two discuss the scam of the ponies, none of whom can now be caught. The other men remark on Ratliff’s intelligence, and Ratliff continues to speculate over who truly owned the ponies, suspecting Flem, though it hasn’t been confirmed. The next day, Mrs. Armstid comes on behalf of her injured husband to get the money the Texan told her she could have reimbursed from Flem. Flem claims the Texan took it all with him when he left. Saint Elmo Snopes, I.O. Snopes’s young son, steals candy from the Varners’ store and is kicked out. Eck and Wall arrive, and it is revealed that the pony the Texan gave them broke its neck and the one they bought got away. The men at the store debate whether Flem will help Mink Snopes now that he has returned before the trial.
In the aftermath of the pony sale, both the Tull and Armstid families decide to sue the Snopeses—the Tulls for the damage to the wagon and the Armstids for Flem’s refusal reimburse them for the horse. Flem Snopes refuses to acknowledge the lawsuits, saying that he never owned the horses. During the Armstid trial, it is revealed that Flem refused to even accept the papers from the court. Lump is there in his stead. The judge is angered by Flem’s absence, but since Mrs. Armstid can’t prove that Flem owned the ponies, he rules against her. Lump helps this outcome by perjuring himself, saying he saw Flem give the Texan the Armstids’ money.
The Tull case then begins, with both Tulls angry at the Snopeses’ tricks during the Armstid case. Eck offers to pay Tull, feeling guilty about his injuries, but it is revealed that since the Texan never gave Eck a bill of sale and that since the horse that ran over Tull was the one the Texan gave to Eck, he never technically owned it and is therefore not liable. The Tulls leave, enraged.
The final trial of the chapter is that of Mink Snopes. Mink, still waiting for Flem to come rescue him, does nothing in his own defense. Flem, despite having returned to the county, does not show up. Mink is found guilty and sentenced to life in prison. He is led away cursing Flem.
Ratliff, Armstid, and another farmer, Bookwright, are together. Bookwright and Ratliff are helping Armstid as he still has a broken leg from the pony rushing him during the auction. They discuss the Old Frenchman’s Place, with Ratliff insisting that he is sure there is some value in it. They head to the property in Ratliff’s wagon, planning to investigate the rumors of a hidden treasure placed there by fleeing Confederate soldiers. They spy Flem Snopes digging on the property. Ratliff emphasizes that they need to find the money in one night or Flem will catch on that there are others looking for it. They agree to bring in “Uncle” Dick Bolivar, a purported local diviner, to find the treasure for them in one night.
The next night, they search the property with Uncle Dick. Eventually, Uncle Dick leads them to a spot and tells them to dig. They find three bags of coins. Ratliff insists that they need to buy the property from Flem immediately, as they can’t explain such a sudden influx of money. Ratliff goes to the store the next day and sees another farmer, Eustace Grimm, who he is convinced was at the Old Frenchman’s Place the night before. He realizes Flem plans to sell the Old Frenchman’s Place to Eustace Grimm. He speaks to Flem and organizes the sale of the Old Frenchman’s Place to him, Armstid, and Bookwright. They spend the next day digging to re-find the treasure. When they finally find it, they realize that it isn’t pre-Civil War currency but much less valuable, recently minted, coins, and that Flem organized the possible sale with Grimm and hid the coins to trick them into buying the property from him.
The town watches as Flem, Eula, and Eula’s child pack up and leave Frenchman’s Bend for Jefferson, Flem having “passed” the small town. The men watching mention how Flem tricked Ratliff, Bookwright, and Armstid. Armstid continues to obsessively dig on the grounds of the Old Frenchman’s Place.
The pony auction shows the rise of “Snopesian” traits within the townspeople, illustrating the power of Ambition as a Threat to the Social Fabric. As usual, Flem appears only on the periphery of the action, and yet his actions have great and destructive effects, inspiring greed and folly in others. The Texan has travelled hundreds of miles to steal from people he’s never met at Flem’s behest, Henry Armstid wastes his family’s last $5 and puts his wife in the path of physical danger, and most men in the town make a bad and dangerous investment. Even Flem’s cousin Eck Snopes is taken in—he sees his son nearly die, is greatly distressed by it, and still ends up “owning” two of the dangerous ponies. This episode is the most dramatic demonstration yet of The Waste of Potential. The ponies have been brought to Mississippi at great expense only to run rampant, causing property damage and endangering lives. The townspeople part with their hard-earned money in a frantic competition to own animals that are worse than useless to them, and the only one to benefit is Flem.
In the aftermath of the pony auction, the town tries to recover from the most audacious of Snopesian schemes yet, bringing both Flem and Eck to trial. This, however, once again goes the Snopeses’ way. The trials show how deeply Snopesian schemes are embedded in the institutions of the county. Flem can refuse to appear, anger the judge, and be at fault, and still he faces no repercussions for the auction and the subsequent destruction of the Armstids’ stability. Eck Snopes’s trial is an example of a different way that corruption has suffused the county. Even as Eck tries to pay the Tulls for the damages they have incurred, the court finds him not liable. Snopesianism has been given such momentum that even without active force behind it, it will protect those with power. As Mrs. Tull states, “You’ll let Eck Snopes or Flem Snopes or that whole Varner tribe snatch you out of the wagon and beat you half to death against a wooden bridge. But when it comes to suing them for your just rights and a punishment, oh no. Because that wouldn’t be neighborly” (328). The real victims, the Armstids and the Tulls, are left with nothing, the narrative making it clear what an uphill battle they were fighting.
Ratliff’s frustration and righteous anger at the Snopeses, particularly Flem, have finally driven him to outright action. His scheme to buy the Old Frenchman’s Place is motivated by a desire to punish Flem, to one-up him, and to take his money for himself. This is the first time Ratliff has acted out of such base motives, and it is the first time Flem manages to trick him. While Ratliff is very intelligent, he cannot beat Flem at his own game. The Old Frenchman’s Place itself is an important symbol in this last section. Dilapidated and apparently worthless, it nonetheless draws Ratliff in with the false promise of Confederate treasure and a chance to recover past wealth. Illusion is the basis of the Old Frenchman’s Place. Beyond the mystique of the treasure and the “Frenchman” who lived there, men like Will Varner and Flem Snopes have conferred value upon the property by claiming to value it themselves. Part of the reason Ratliff gave in to his desire to buy the property in the first place is that he had trust in Will’s ability to assess the value of something, not believing that he would have kept the property for so long if there wasn’t some inherent value to it. The mythos of these powerful men is reinforced by their own actions, a self-perpetuating system.
The end of the novel sees Flem departing at last, leaving Frenchman’s Bend for the larger town of Jefferson. Managing to trick Ratliff seems to have been the final challenge for Flem in Frenchman’s Bend, and having done so, he can at last move on. Bringing a still silent and unfulfilled Eula with him, he has sucked the town dry without appearing to do much at all. Like the “Frenchman” discussed at the beginning of the book, Flem is poised to fade into legend and folklore, a shadowy figure pulling the strings in the background, amassing wealth from the less powerful people he scams. The final image, of Armstid desperately digging for the treasure, is emblematic of the false promises and the ruin Flem leaves behind him.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By William Faulkner