77 pages • 2 hours read
During the summer of 1955, Audre works at the library and Muriel does odd jobs for their friends. On the weekends, they go to bars and write poetry. They read books from the library and used bookstores. Bea’s ex-lover, Lynn, comes to live with them. Before she dated Bea, Lynn was married to a man who died in a car crash, and now Lynn lives with the guilt. Audre admits to herself that she is attracted to Lynn, and she and Muriel and Lynn discuss the possibility of collective love: “What we were trying to build was dangerous, and could have enormous consequences for Muriel and me” (212). Audre believes her love for Muriel is strong enough to withstand being tested.
Audre shows up to work without sleeping on many occasions, making up a story about her sick boyfriend. She comes home one day to find Muriel and Lynn getting out of bed together. She is partially furious, but then goes to bed with Lynn herself. They focus their attentions on Lynn; Audre gets her a job at another library and a different apartment, although she spends most of her time in their apartment. They believed they were trendsetters in communal lesbian sex, as they had never read anything that came close to what they were trying to do. Although they tried to avoid hurt feelings, eventually Lynn realized that she was a visitor in Audre and Muriel’s relationship. She leaves abruptly one day, stealing Audre’s savings: “Even many years afterward, Lynn was never able to say to us why she had done it” (214).
Muriel and Audre take a course in contemporary American poetry, and Audre goes into therapy. Audre rarely speaks, mostly listening, and she and Muriel “communicated pretty much by intuition and unfinished sentences” (215). Audre enjoys her time at the library because she doesn’t have to talk unless she’s reading stories to children. Audre decides she wants to go back to college because she equates a degree with freedom. Money is tight, so for Thanksgiving they steal a bunch of food from a supermarket. Audre believes that as long as they need the food, they won’t get caught stealing. They only steal when they need to and never get caught.
Audre announces she’s going back to school. Audre and Muriel exchange presents on Christmas Eve and spend Christmas with their respective families. Audre does not tell her family about her relationship with Muriel, although they know she is Audre’s roommate: “my family only allowed themselves to know whatever it was they cared to know, and I did not push them as long as they left me alone” (216).
For New Year’s Eve, Audre and Muriel go to a wealthy white lesbian couple’s party, although Audre enjoys the parties at her black friends’ houses much more, finding them more lively and full of food. Audre quietly inspects books on shelves, while Muriel circulates effortlessly. Audre and Muriel leave the party shortly after midnight and wander through the streets; Audre feels very blessed to not be lonely and remembers it is their first anniversary. They go home and make love. Muriel makes food, and their friends come over and then leave. Audre and Muriel write, and when Audre looks at Muriel’s notebook, she finds a list of things she has done last year next to Muriel’s “NOTHING!” (219). Audre is heartbroken that Muriel is comparing their achievements and finding herself lacking.
Audre goes out to a lesbian bar, passing the bouncer who keeps out undesirables: “All too frequently, undesirable meant Black” (220). She feels like an outsider because she is frequently the only black woman in the bar. Audre feels the pressure of 1950s pretense that everything is okay, especially within the split between aggressive butches who might beat her up and their objectified femmes: “Role-playing reflected all the depreciating attitudes towards women which we loathed in straight society” (221). Many of the gay bars have free Sunday brunch, which she and Muriel go to. Being around other lesbians while enjoying a free meal is like finding family. Most gay bars failed within a year; during the summer, Muriel and Audre go from the gay beach to the bars to eat.
One day, Audre confronts a white lesbian acquaintance for her racist remark. The woman comments on Audre’s tan, joking, “’I didn’t know Negroes got tans’” (223). The woman’s girlfriend, nervous, keeps commenting on how beautiful Audre’s skin is, and Audre asks her why she keeps talking about it. Muriel laughs, but everyone else is silent. Audre reflects on how she longed for black lesbian companionship because many black lesbians were closeted or into heavy roles. Even these women, usually loaded with money and accompanied by a gorgeous femme, often couldn’t get into the bars simply because they were black. Being black forced you to be strong in order to survive. Racism and misogyny returned in full force after the end of World War II, and often the gay bars were the only place Audre felt like she could escape oppression, albeit relatively. More than anything, Audre feels different: “It was a while before we came to realize that our place was the very house of difference rather than the security of any one particular difference” (226). Often, this would lead black lesbians down a path of self-destruction, which, in Flee’s case, involved heroin.
In the spring of 1956, Audre has to stop therapy because she and Muriel run out of money. Muriel still cannot look for a job, which Audre begins to resent. Audre dreams that Muriel gets run over by a train and Audre cannot stop it. Muriel cannot sleep, reading and writing or going out drinking: “Sometimes I felt we were as lost to each other as if one of us were dead” (227). Muriel stops eating, living off beer and cigarettes. They run into Jill, an old friend from The Branded and someone whom Audre has always felt a mutual attraction, although both ignore it. Muriel, Audre, and Jill begin typing poems at Jill’s father’s office downtown.
Audre runs into Toni, another friend from high school, and they go out for a drink. Audre learns that Toni is gay, has her own car, and works as a registered nurse. Audre is impressed by her friend’s success. Toni starts hanging out with Muriel because Audre is in night school. Muriel asks Audre if she can sleep with Toni: “My stabs of jealousy were tempered by my lessening sense of guilt; for what, I could not say” (230). Audre remembers the disruption Lynn caused, as well as her mother’s crying when her father was out all night, but pushes these feelings down, believing that their love is forever. After incorporating Toni into their lives, Muriel seems to get better. Audre is enjoying school.
Audre wakes up one night to hear Jill and Muriel making love. She feels betrayed because she has unfinished history with Jill and they are in the next room. Audre is furious when she wakes up, but Muriel is not there. During a staff meeting at the library, Audre purposefully pours boiling water on her hand to try to take her mind off the emotional pain of Muriel and Jill. She goes to the doctor, and Muriel says nothing. Audre is embarrassed by her self-mutilation. Audre and Muriel never speak about Jill, who disappears, or about Audre’s accident.
Muriel has an affair with another woman who is also in a relationship. Audre knows she is slipping away but cannot seem to let her go; Muriel also cannot seem to leave: “We could destroy each other, but we could not move beyond our pain […] love was no longer enough of an answer” (234). Audre yells at her, and Muriel is silent. Muriel falls in love with the woman, and Audre becomes depressed. Sometimes she walks in front of the other woman’s house with a knife, knowing Muriel is in there. Audre cannot accept that their life together is over. Muriel often does not come home for days, and Audre wanders the streets. Audre calls her mother, and Linda asks after Muriel. Audre gets dropped out of summer school due to attendance. When Toni teaches Audre how to swim underwater, she tells Audre Muriel’s not worth it because she’s crazy.
Marie calls, having escaped her husband’s white slavery ring, and Audre goes to visit her in Detroit. When Audre gets back, she finds that Muriel has half-painted the kitchen but left paint out which the starving kittens got into and died from. Audre buries them in the park. Muriel “had loved the kittens, and she’d let them die” (238).
In September, amidst the fervor of Elvis Presley, Audre gets on a bus to hear music swelling in her head which no one else hears: “The physical realities of the dingy bus slid away from me. I suddenly stood upon a hill in the center of an unknown country, hearing the sky fill with a new spelling of my name” (239).
Muriel slowly moves out of their apartment. One night, Audre comes home to find Muriel asleep amidst her semi-packed clothes. She wakes up and catches Audre staring at her, and Audre realizes that Muriel belongs to herself. Audre begins stopping by the bars, and often Audre finds Muriel drunk and crying in the corners of bars, reminding her of Eudora. Sometimes she puts her to bed but eventually she gets fed up and leaves Muriel in the bar. Muriel burns her journals and poems, leaving a mark on the apartment’s linoleum, before going back to Stamford and signing herself into the psychiatric ward where Toni worked.
These chapters show the destruction of Muriel and Audre’s relationship. Audre paints the end of their relationship as a kind of death, drawing similarities between Muriel and Gennie. Audre mourns both the death of the relationship and Muriel’s descent into schizophrenia, and is reminded of Gennie’s slide into a deep depression and eventual suicide. Audre knows that the end of the relationship is near, and while she half-accepts that it is beyond her control, she also deeply desires to fix things. She is conflicted, shadowed by a looming presence of death. The audience sees the actual death of the kittens, signifying the end of the relationship, as Audre knows that Muriel still loves her but can do nothing to salvage their love, just as she could not help the kittens, who were killed by Muriel’s neglect.
The audience also witnesses Muriel’s death in Audre’s dream, reinforcing the similarities between Muriel and Gennie in which Audre feels just as powerless as she did when she was a teenager. There is a circularity to this pain and trauma, as though Audre never accepted Gennie’s death; it is only through the death of their relationship that Audre comes to terms with what it means to lose a loved one. At first, she uses physical pain as a replacement for her anger, but eventually realizes that even physical pain is no match for psychological pain, and her refusal to accept reality dissipates. Audre realizes that their differences are stronger than her need for self-preservation, which she found in her relationship to Muriel, although the audience understands that the end of the relationship is the only way that Audre can survive.
These chapters also portray Audre’s critique of homosexual culture, as she finds its to be an extension of straight society. Homosexual culture still abides by the same racist norms, especially concerning apparel. Those who do not dress correctly within the butch/femme binary, such as Audre, are outsiders. In this way, Audre recognizes oppression as oppression, realizing that just because a person is oppressed, it does not mean that she is not perpetuating the same norms of oppression. Specifically, Audre finds the concept of female beauty to be an extension of the white male gaze, leaving no place for her within its vision. These chapters also illustrate the danger of bucking convention, as homosexual refuges become a safer place, but not necessarily a completely safe place, within an overwhelmingly hostile society.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Audre Lorde